Skip to content

The Invasion of the Lionfish

May 26, 2011


The lionfish.  The majestic fish of the reef.  It is beautiful, fearless, deadly, and increasingly ubiquitous.  Native to the Indo-Pacific region, it has spread far and wide in the past twenty years and is now a serious problem in the Caribbean and along the east coast of the United States. (Though no one knows why; one theory is lionfish escaped from aquariums after Hurricane Andrew.)

Scientists, fishermen, scuba divers, and the broader public should all be concerned as there are no natural predators to control the lionfish’s numbers outside of its traditional range.  As one marine park manager told me in Roatan, Hondursas:

They eat everything and they breed like cockroaches.  If a fish can fit in its mouth, we’ve found it in the lionfish’s belly.

As a result, the lionfish invasion – combined with climate change, overfishing, siltification, and pollution – is speeding along the destruction of Caribbean reefs.

As a scuba diver, I’ve seen this damage myself.  Between 2006 and 2010, I was able to see the changes caused by the arrival of lionfish in Honduras’ Bay Islands.  Small fish, such as gobies, hamlets, and fairy basslets  clearly declined in abundance.  Also, I couldn’t be sure, but it did seem like there were fewer juvenile snapper.

But of course, I could also strangely marvel at the invasion.  The lionfish are beautiful; their long plumes fanning in the currents, their utter confidence that you can do them no harm as you approach.  I would think sometimes that my enjoyment was something akin to admiring a fire as it consumes my own home.

And just as strange, after years of teaching divers to respect the reef creatures, there I was pointing out the lionfish to my divers and then asking our assistant to spear the creature as part of the on-going eradication efforts.

The lionfish hand sign

Eradication, however, will only ever be an aspiration unless we find more effective methods.   The marine park manager in Roatan explained that his hunters could only go down to recreational limits (130 feet) while lionfish range much deeper.  And their regular breeding means that hunters simply can’t keep up.   For example, just recently in the Florida Keys, a derby yielded 531 lionfish catches, and the fishermen remarked that they were more numerous and bigger than ever.

Here is a video of a lionfish hunt off Cozumel

What else can be done?  Some conservationists in Honduras are trying to teach native sharks to feed on lionfish, but there are doubts to the practicability of this technique.  Even if it works, a vast number of reef sharks would need to be conditioned since most live within small territories.

In my own opinion, I think we just haven’t found our solution yet.  I wonder if perhaps there would be an opportunity for specialized traps or fishing gear to “tame” the lionfish.  This might take some investment, but perhaps we might have the market someday on our side.  Lionfish apparently make delicious meals and consumer demand is growing in the Caribbean.

On a menu near you soon?

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: